Stabbing Your Husband While He Sleeps is Bad for Your Financial Future

Mental illnessA woman judged insane at the time she stabbed her husband is not entitled to pension benefits as his surviving spouse, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit.

The Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) generally would require the pension plan to pay the benefits to the woman, because she was the surviving spouse.   However, Illinois has a “slayer statute” that bans a person from financially benefiting from the murder of another.

The federal court of appeals ruled that ERISA doesn’t preempt Illinois’ slayer statute. The Seventh Circuit agreed with the courts that have held that ERISA doesn’t preempt state slayer laws in North Dakota, New York, and Nevada. Most states have adopted these statutes, but the U.S. Supreme Court has chosen not to address the issue at least twice.

The Seventh Circuit noted that the notion that an individual who kills a plan participant can’t recover plan benefits, “is a well-established legal principle which predates ERISA.”

The Seventh Circuit also rejected the woman’s argument that the Illinois state law didn’t apply to her because she was found not guilty by reason of insanity.  However, based on a decision by an Illinois appeals court, the judges held that the Illinois slayer law does apply to bar recovery by individuals who commit a killing but are found not guilty of murder by reason of insanity.

What exactly did the woman do? She intentionally stabbed her husband in his sleep, then she intentionally hit him with a bat to keep him from calling the police, the judges said.  Although she was not able to understand the criminality of her conduct, she intended her actions, the Court of Appeals said.  Judge Joel M. Flaum issued the opinion, which was joined by Judges Michael S. Kanne, and Ilana Diamond Rovner.

It seems to me that the untold story here is the sad state of mental health care in this, one of the richest nations in the world.  Why would an obviously insane woman, who posed a danger to others, not be receiving treatment for her mental illness? 

Like this article?

Share on facebook
Share on Facebook
Share on twitter
Share on Twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on Linkdin
Share on pinterest
Share on Pinterest

Leave a comment


We have a LOT more where that came from!

We hate spam too. We will never share or sell your information.

Call Now ButtonCall Us Now https://jsfiddle.net/7h5246b8/

Request a free consultation

We hate spam too. We will never share or sell your information.

We've been putting together as many resources as possible so that we can continue to help:

  • If you’re a current client with a signing appointment or a prospective client with a consultation and would prefer that meeting take place in your own home, we can accomplish that with a little bit of pre-planning on our part and with the addition of a laptop, smartphone, tablet or other computer in your home to facilitate this virtual meeting. For those of you that need to sign legal documents, that too can be accomplished with the use of a webcam (FaceTime etc.), so that we can witness and electronically notarize all of your important legal documents.
  • We launched the rollout of our on-demand webinar early so that new clients and our allied professionals can view the important component parts of ‘an estate plan that works’ at their convenience.  That is available on our website.
  • Live video workshops will be produced as quickly as possible and certainly ahead of our previous schedule; we will keep you posted as these events become available. Given the ‘boutique’ nature of the firm, we rarely have more than ten people in our office including team members at any one time. During this period of ‘social distancing,’ we promise to have no more than 8 people at any time.   This allows us to comply with the Governor’s directive to limit in-person gatherings.
  • The best way to communicate with us is still by phone during regular office hours of 8:30 to 5:00, Monday through Friday, or, you can email any of our team members (that is, their first name followed by @zarembalaw.com).  We will respond to these emails as quickly as possible.
  • Please continue to follow the directives of our local, state, and federal agencies. For your health and in consideration of our team who is assisting you, if you’ve scheduled an office appointment or planned to drop off paperwork and are experiencing a fever, dry cough, or shortness of breath, please contact your primary care doctor for guidance and then our office to reschedule.

Thank you, Walt and the Zaremba Team

Update to our Process

The unprecedented coronavirus pandemic has taken our entire country by surprise. We understand how difficult this time is for America’s businesses and families.  However, we believe it is vitally important that we make every effort possible to continue to offer solutions that avoid disrupting our important partnership with you, your family and friends.  As you know, estate planning is not something that should wait for a more convenient time, therefore the opportunity to address your important goals both during and after this crisis should not wait.  To that end, we have added the option of a ‘virtual consultation’ to our office process.  You will now have a choice of either meeting with us in our office or in the comfort of your own home.